Hurricane Katrina Donations Could be Many Millions More - EBay Sellers Try in Vain to Help


Yesterday I saw a mention in someone's email ezine about a kind person who had an eBay auction with the proceeds going 100% to help victims of the horrible Hurricane Katrina.

It struck a chord with me because I had wanted to set up something similar, but found that the "eBay Giving Works" charity program seems to be terribly flawed for us small sellers. I had researched it the day before, eBay goes through Mission Fish to handle the administrative tasks and distribution.

Here in a nutshell is how I understand it works. You set up an eBay auction and pledge a percentage of the proceeds to go to a charity. You pick the one you like. If the auction sells, the buyer pays you, and Mission Fish charges your credit card, taking out $3.00 per transaction for their fees, plus 3% to cover credit card fees. That's reasonable, they need to cover their overhead and payroll expenses. Then Mission Fish sends the balance to the charity.

The minimum donation per item has to be $10.00. Again, so far so good, I can understand that.

Now, I noticed in the auction that I visited that the seller had set up a dutch auction, with 1000 "lots" available, each for $1.00 each, with the proceeds going 100% to her favorite charity that would get food to the Katrina victims. I was about to place a bid for several $1.00 lots (a dutch auction lets you "win" as many of the item as you like, all at the same price).

Then it hit me, why couldn't I do the same kind of dutch auction, maybe she had found the way to get around the $10.00 per item restriction, and found that it was a minimum $10.00 per auction. It would only make sense that it would work that way, since Mission Fish charges the seller's credit card, if all 1000 lots sold, that would be $1000 for the charity, Mission Fish would take $3.00 plus 3%, the seller would collect (hopefully) the $1000 from the buyers, and all she would be on the hook for would be the eBay fees. Those fees, plus her hard work, would be her personal contribution.

So I went back to eBay and Mission Fish and researched the deal again. I found out that sure enough, in a multiple item auction, Mission Fish requires a $10.00 donation from the seller for EVERY ITEM that sells in a multiple-item auction (dutch auction).

So, if the seller had 1000 lots at $1.00 each, and they all sold, Mission Fish would have charged her credit card on file for $10.00 for each lot, a total of $10,000.00! And they would have taken their $3.00 + 3% fee for each of those 1000 lots, more than $3,000.00 for their trouble!

At that point, I realized the seller either had deep pockets and was matching contributions 10 to 1, or she misunderstood what would happen to her. I sent her an email, and to end a long story, she indeed misunderstood, was obviously fairly upset at the prospect of paying $10,000, and ended the auction early.

Now, I'd like my readers to do one of two things. If you think that eBay and Mission Fish are mishandling the charity program, as I do, please contact one or both and point them to this blog entry, or just write your own letter with your thoughts.

You can contact Mission Fish here:
http://www.missionfish.org/Help/contactus.jsp

eBay is always more difficult to contact, but you can try starting here:
http://pages.ebay.com/help/contact_us/_base/index.html

The other thing you could do is support the eBay seller's cause, she had to end the auction but she took the trouble to set up a web page for donations, you can access and support it here:
http://www.flipidy.com/secondharvest.htm

Perhaps with enough pressure on Mission Fish, they'll get together with eBay and allow dutch auctions to be counted as a single donation, instead of multiple individual items, and encourage more charity in the future.

For those with homes, families, relatives or friends in the devasted area, my hearts and prayers go out to you. I hope this information will in some small way help someone somewhere.

Dennis Becker is author of a regular blog about different ways of earning money on the Internet, titled appropriately enough "Success On The Internet".







Related News



Sports fans vie for memorabilia at Ohio auction - Akron Beacon Journal

Sports fans vie for memorabilia at Ohio auction
Akron Beacon Journal, OH -4 hours ago
Fans now own pieces of Ohio sports history after digging deep into their pockets during an auction in Cincinnati. Sunday's sale featured items from the ...
Auction draws sports fans, cashCincinnati.com
Sports collectibles on blockCincinnati.com
all 10 news articles

• Big Papi bed auction winner one classy dude - The Republican - MassLive.com

• Big Papi bed auction winner one classy dude
The Republican - MassLive.com, MA -2 hours ago
RSM: What drew you to the auction? It's obviously a worthy cause, but many fans might have scared away by the high cost of bidding. ...

Bidz.com Launches Arabic-Language Version of Its Popular Online ... - Business Wire (press release)

Bidz.com Launches Arabic-Language Version of Its Popular Online ...
Business Wire (press release), CA -5 hours ago
The Arabic-language site is the second in a series of non-English sites, which will seek to tap into the auction site’s attractiveness around the world and ...
Bidz.com Launches Arabic Language WebsiteDiamonds.net
all 10 news articles

Credit crunch crushes art auction - BBC News

Reuters

Credit crunch crushes art auction
BBC News, UK -5 hours ago
Asia's contemporary art market suffered a blow at the weekend as bidders failed to buy several paintings at a major Sotheby's auction in Hong Kong. ...
Masriadi Breaks Post-Lehman Stupor at Hong Kong Art AuctionBloomberg
Pop Goes the Bubble in Chinese & Indian ArtBusinessWeek
Weak Sales for Sotheby's in Hong KongWall Street Journal
BusinessWeek - Bloomberg
all 43 news articles

Treasury Department Releases Response to Bailout Bill - RTT News

Treasury Department Releases Response to Bailout Bill
RTT News, NY -1 hour ago
In the statement, Anthony Ryan said the Treasury Department would make "adjustments to the auction calendar" in order to "address the increased funding ...
The Fed gained the authority to pay interest on reserves under the ...Bloomberg
Treasury announces plan to boost debt auctionsWhite Rock Reviewer
all 213 news articles

Fed's to offer $150 bln in TAF auction today - Forbes

Boston Globe

Fed's to offer $150 bln in TAF auction today
Forbes, NY -2 hours ago
WASHINGTON (Thomson Financial) - The US Federal Reserve today will auction $150 bln to depository institutions through its Term Auction Facility (TAF) in an ...
Fed lends $5.88 bln Treasuries to dealers at auctionReuters
Fed pumps billions more into banksCNNMoney.com
Feds Takes Steps to Boost LiquidityTheStreet.com
Bloomberg - Reuters
all 471 news articles

Auction house eBay axes 1000 jobs - guardian.co.uk

ABC News

Auction house eBay axes 1000 jobs
guardian.co.uk, UK -4 hours ago
Online auction house eBay is axing 1000 jobs or 10% of its global workforce as it looks to save $150m (£85m) a year in the face of slowing sales, ...
EBay Will Cut 10% of Jobs as Auction Growth Slows (Update1)Bloomberg
Auction anxiety - eBay cutting 1600 jobsExaminer.com
eBay Workforce High Bidder in Pink Slip AuctionAll Things D Blogs
Los Angeles Times - International Herald Tribune
all 569 news articles

BoE's $10 bln overnight auction covered 1.05 times - Forbes

BoE's $10 bln overnight auction covered 1.05 times
Forbes, NY -8 hours ago
LONDON, Oct 6 (Reuters) - The Bank of England said on Monday it received bids worth 1.05 times the amount on offer in its auction of $10 billion overnight ...

Vectren Ohio Conducts Natural Gas Auction on World Energy Exchange - Canada NewsWire (press release)

Vectren Ohio Conducts Natural Gas Auction on World Energy Exchange
Canada NewsWire (press release), Canada -5 hours ago
The auction resulted in a retail price adjustment of $2.35 per thousand cubic feet (Mcf), which will be in effect from October 1, 2008 through March 31, ...

Auction clearance rates healthy - The Age

Courier Mail

Auction clearance rates healthy
The Age, Australia -12 hours ago
Claims by a Sydney-based research company that auction clearance rates across Australia will remain at record lows unless interest rates are "reduced ...
Property comeback on holdThe Australian
all 16 news articles